Credit Card Use Dissuades Saving for Emergencies
I was talking to Mark (the proudly self proclaimed Financial Retard) about how he was getting by without using his credit cards over the past few weeks. He said a funny thing happened when he pulled the cards out of his wallet, for the first time in many years he had the feeling that he needed to save more. As it turns out he was pretty freaked out by the fact that he didn’t have his “debt safety net” to fall back on. Mark was used to always having a $1,000 or so in available credit just in case something popped up. Now that he was no longer carting those cards he was only relying only on the money in his bank account.
Having a credit card to fall back on can dissuade you from building a proper emergency fund. I think this happens for a couple reasons. First, with credit you already have a safety net in place. That’s actually one of the reasons many people get credit cards in the first place. Though this can quickly blow up in your face because you could be taking on debt at the exact time it gets most difficult to pay it back. It amazes me how many people grab their credit cards right after a job loss and began using high interest cash advances for everyday life at the exact worse time to be borrowing money. I think having the cards as a safety net allows people to feel like they’re covered so the urgency to save really isn’t there.
Second, I think another reason people don’t build emergency savings when they use cards is because they’re constantly working to clear the debts. Instead of making savings a priority they make keeping up with the card balances a priority. The more debt they have on their cards the less they have available to save and the more likely they’ll need the cards to cover their butts again and so the cycle continues.
At some point if you want to go with out credit cards you need to break the cycle of spending instead of saving. I personally stashed away a little dough to use for future “emergencies” then stopped using the cards. Once I stopped using the cards and had some real money in the bank to fall back on all I really had to do was eliminate the balances and at that point I was done with the credit card cycle. I had no use for them anymore. I now have an emergency fund with more money available to me than I ever had available on my credit cards…oh and it’s earning interest too.
The good news is Mark has decided, for the first time ever, to start saving. He’s now quickly building an emergency fund since this’ll be his only safety net going forward. It looks like with a little encouragement and some discipline our buddy Mark won’t be “financially retarded” too much longer…at least that’s the plan.
So what’s your plan for dealing with credit cards, do you want them gone, do you really need them around? Let me know how you feel about this.














...."so when I got home we had a talk and decided this money situation had to change. I didn’t know how I was going to change it, we were barely making enough money to cover the monthly payments so how the H-E-double-hockey-sticks was I going to fix it?"
Interesting post. I agree that everyone need emergency funds and shouldn’t rely on credit card as the only source of income in an emergency.
But I see credit cards and savings as two very different tools in my financial toolbox – they are not substitutes for each other. Savings / liquid assets are SOURCES of money I use for payment. Credit cards are a METHOD (like cash, check, debit card, PayPal, etc.) of payment.
I have an emergency fund and I have credit cards, and I don’t confuse my credit card as a source of money. That way, I enjoy the benefits of credit cards (fraud protection, virtual numbers when purchasing items online, award points, etc.) without damaging my personal finances.
1I agree with WellHeeled. My cash back credit cards are not an emergency savings fund but rather just a method of payment that just so happens to make me 1% – 3% cash back
2CC Chaser & WellHeeled,
3I think thats great that you use the cards as tools. My hope is that more people will use them in that manner instead of in place of a sound financial plan. Using them as a tool can have it’s benefits for those that have the disciplne, knowledge and self control to manage them well.